Showing posts with label Personal Experiences. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Personal Experiences. Show all posts

Saturday, December 24, 2016

Excrement in North Carolina

      The news came in yesterday that North Carolina's state legislature voted not to repeal their law that requires transgendered individuals to use public bathrooms that correspond with their birth gender.  This, despite several long hours of deals between legislators.  Also after months of intense public protest, media scrutiny, and boycotting.
      I have to keep reminding myself that this senseless prejudice is born out of ignorance.  Gender is a critical part of personal identity.  For people who feel grounded in their gender, the idea of wanting to be otherwise can be really baffling, even terrifying.  And if they don't know anybody who is transgender their imaginations can take them to a lot of frightening places.  I understand this reaction, because I'm human: my instincts when faced with something totally outside my realm of experience is confusion and discomfort.  It has taken work to get to a place where I can catch myself*, and check and challenge my assumptions.
Humor is a great way to get people to stop and think, but sadly, there is very little that is funny about this issue.  Transgender women (women who were born as males) experience the highest rate of assault and murder.
      This piece in the news has me thinking a lot about Gender Privilege.  Of course there is the obvious discrepancy in how men and women are treated, but there's more to it than that.  When someone identifies as other than their birth gender - and that identity may not fit into a neat, binary model - sexism complicates matters even further.  Because gender is not just a biological phenomenon, it's also a social one.  A person who was born a male and transitions to female gives up a hell of a lot of privilege.  Honestly, they probably won't even receive the same privileges as a biologically-born female, unless they can pass really, really well.  It's not the physical, but the social aspects of gender that makes being a member of the trans community so dangerous.
       Recently at a training on working with transgendered youth, the presenter asked us all to imagine waking up tomorrow with our genders reversed.**  The trainer explained that those strong negative reactions are akin to what trans kids feel when they undergo puberty.  All of a sudden their body is becoming more sexualized, except that it's turning out to be something that feels foreign.  They live this feeling every day, and for many it only gets worse with time.
      The exercise was to help people understand and empathize.  In talking with my fellow trainees afterward, I was surprised by the spectrum of responses to imaging waking up with different genitals.  Some people felt shock.  Others felt curiosity.  Some said they felt revulsion, or panic.  A few people said they couldn't participate in the mental exercise, because the idea was literally inconceivable to them: they just couldn't force their imagination to go there.
      It reminded me of my college days, when I cut my hair very short (a "boy cut") and tended to wear baggy pants and flannels.  My reasons were simple: I wasn't vain, and this look was both comfortable and convenient.  But I was mistaken for a male from the back more than once.  On one memorable occasion, a well-meaning salesperson at a high-end retail establishment tried to remove me from the women's dressing room.  My reaction to this was anger.  I remember turning around in shock and gripping my chest to make a point.  She was completely mortified, apologized profusely.  Later, when I got over my anger, it made for a funny story.  But now I think back on that and wonder what precisely made me so mad.
      It's not like I didn't know that I wasn't presenting in stereotypical gender fashion.  Nor was that the first time someone had made that error when seeing me from behind.  I'd like to say that my feelings were born of a deep feminist belief that a woman isn't defined by her looks--especially not her clothing and hair.  But that's too cerebral; my reaction was reflexive.  In retrospect, I think it was because being faced with a limitation based on my perceived gender - even for a few seconds - was offensive to my feeling of identity.  And what's more, because it was someone trying to ban me from a space where  I felt instinctively that I belonged, I felt threatened.
      That was a small, small incident in my own life, but I am trying to use it to come to a better understanding of how I experience Gender Privilege.  For some people it is easier to be an ally to people with different skin, because of course we are born that way, it's nobody's choice, and therefore it's nobody's fault, so prejudice based on skin color is inherently unfair.  But being transgender seems to many to be a choice.  More than that, it seems an incomprehensible choice.  So they don't experience the same level of alliance.  We can all empathize with being treated unfairly for something that isn't our fault; it's harder to grasp making what seems to be such a radical - in some cases incomprehensible - choice.
      I think what these people are missing is understanding what kind of choice it is to become a transgendered person.  Most of us are not faced with a choice to be who we are, or not.  We were born with the privilege of having most of our life choices fall within a spectrum acceptable to our sense of self.  I am going to try harder to be aware of that privilege.  The truth is, I admire people who are true to themselves, no matter what.  I just want to develop a deeper understanding of what that means, for everyone.



*Most of the time, I'm not perfect.

**People are beginning to understand that gender is not binary, but for the purposes of this presentation it made the most sense to present the language in these terms.

Friday, December 16, 2016

Reflections on Safety Pin Training

      Last weekend, I taught a free community training on de-escalation skills.  It was my friend's idea: she's far more involved in social media than I am and she saw both an interest and a need.  She reached out to me, she found a location, and she put out the word.  She is amazing.  And over 20 people showed up.
      Over 20 people came to learn ways to put themselves between an aggressor and a targeted individual.  They came to learn how to help others - help strangers - because they believe in embodying the values of equity and inclusion.  It was humbling.  I know it sounds corny, but I was honestly deeply moved that these individuals were willing to learn, and willing to act.  It's nice to know we're not alone.
      I am a privileged individual who, by no other means than the color of my skin, am a member of a broad and comfortable majority.  It is exceedingly rare for me to go anywhere and feel out-of-place, and when I do it's usually by choice.  But for the first few days after the election I didn't feel that way.  Everywhere I went, every White stranger I looked at, I wondered: "Who is this person?  How did they vote, and why?  What are their values?"  I was trying to read facial expressions like never before.  Were they happy or sad?  Elated that their "underdog" candidate had made it?  Or did they feel like me, distressed that such an ugly side of America had been exposed, and proved so much larger than they had feared?  It is my nature to assume that everyone is a good person when I first meet them.  All of a sudden, I was questioning that.
      My paranoia had died down a little bit since then.  Logic, education, and experience have tempered my emotions into a more reasonable perspective.  After all, not everyone who voted for Trump is an overtly racist hate-monger.  At least one person I know and love has financial convictions that blinded them to the larger social issues.  And there are people who weren't appalled by Trump's rhetoric because it echoed that of most people they know.  To them, it must have been refreshing - maybe even a relief - to finally have a presidential candidate who sounded like "a real person."  They might have experienced the precise opposite of my reaction following the election.  Maybe all of a sudden they felt more like they belonged.
      For me, the sense of isolation continued.  It wasn't until I walked into the room last Saturday and saw those strangers - those wonderful, caring, daring strangers - that I realized how much I was carrying around.  All of a sudden, here was the Seattle I knew and loved: people ranging in age from early 20's to late 50's; ranging in style from conservative slacks to heavy piercings and blue hair; and from the way they were dressed, there was no way to know what the socio-economic spread might be.*  I felt like a member of a community again.  I felt like strangers and I had something in common again.
      It fueled me.  It humbled me.  It stoked the embers of my hope.  It made me feel so, so thankful that I had something to give.  And it made me hungry to learn more, myself.
      If you were there: thank you for coming.
      We'll be doing a repeat of the first training in January, and then moving on to other topics of request later in the winter.  I will have the slides made available soon.  Another friend of mine and I will be coordinating some open trainings and forums about race discrepancy and White Privilege in south Seattle.  I hope to see some of the same people back again, and I hope to see plenty of new faces, too.  We're not alone. As I've been writing in my holiday cards: 2017 may not be shaping up to be the best year, but it can bring out the best in us.

*Of course everyone was White: the Safety Pin movement is about recognizing privilege and becoming an ally.  But you certainly don't have to be White!

Sunday, October 9, 2016

Support in Unexpected Places

      I spent this last weekend in Seattle attending Geek Girl Con.  I went because I am essentially a nerdy person, with interests ranging from Star Trek to Star Wars, from fantasy novels to anime, and from video games to cosplay.  In other words, I went to find other women such as myself: I went to feel like a part of a community.
      Women are under-represented or exploited in much of geek culture.  We're often hyper-sexualized, as brilliantly highlighted in The Hawkeye Initiative.  In movies and novels, we're often slotted as support characters whose main purpose is to back-up the male protagonist.  Or worse, we're often redshirted or fridged as a means to further the plot.  The purpose of Geek Girl Con is to identify, discuss, and support healthy and positive use of female characters, and the women who work in geeky industries such as computer science or the comic industry.
      I am happy to report that I got what I wanted out of the experience.  Every minute of the convention, I was surrounded by other people who shared not only my interests, but were willing to be brave about it.  I'm even happier to say that the support was not limited to just women--not by a long shot.  This was a convention that takes pride in being a voice of social justice: ethnic minorities, LGBTQ minorities, religious minorities, and all body types and abilities were being supported, loud and clear.
      I learned about so many wonderful aspects of nerd culture I'd never known before.  I discovered the Gaymer community, and learned about how they're working to eliminate homophobia in video games at every level.  I learned about organizations that support differently-abled individuals in accessing video games, both for pleasure and as a means to support physical activity.  I learned about women taking control of their bodies and drawing healthy boundaries by enjoying cosplay without being victimized.
      But I was most deeply stirred when I learned about "Blerds." The term refers to self-identified Black Nerds who are building a community of their own, and calling out for strong and positive representation.  In the last panel I attended, I got to hear Blerd journalist Valerie Complex describe her experiences of being shunted to the side again and again, not taken seriously as a writer or a geek.  She talked about how businesses and organizations would claim to be diverse--then she would show up, and find that she was the only non-white person there.  She also talked about how these same groups would bemoan how "no minorities every show up, no black people every apply!"  Her answer to this was so simple and yet so profound: she said that these same organizations don't reach out.  She asked why they had not attended meetings, festivals, or job fairs in the Black community.  She said, "If you don't go to their party to show your interest and support, why would you assume they would want to come to your party?  Why would they feel safe doing so?"
      It immediately struck me how this was true for so many groups, not just employers or conventions.  It's true for political groups.  It's even true for social services.  Outreach is essential in every area, and that's true of individuals as well.  I hope to be more mindful of this concept myself, moving forward on my own journey to being a better Ally.

Sunday, September 11, 2016

My First Introduction to U.S. Race Relations

      When one is born into privilege, one could easily go one's entire life without ever realizing it.  As I'm fond saying: it's hard to convince a free swimming fish that it's wet.  That fish has just never known anything else, and unless it is literally pulled out of it's comfort zone, it might not be able to conceive of anything different.  For this reason, I believe that it's important to teach kids - especially White kids - about racism.
      I think a lot about my understanding of racism growing up.  I'm deeply grateful that I experienced no overt racism in my family.  My parents and extended family all believed in racial equality the way any ordinary person would believe in gravity.  I never heard a single racial stereotype growing up, and I never knew a single racial slur until I learned about them in a historical context.  I think the first time I heard the "n word" was reading Mark Twain in middle school.
This book includes the words "injun" and "nigger."  For that reason, it has been re-edited for some schools, and banned in others.  Still other people believe it is critical to leave the original story as it's written, because it offers a valuable insight into history.  What's your perspective?
      In some ways, I think this was a great way to grow up.  My mind wasn't poisoned with any senseless, stupid, cruel biases around skin color.  Thank the Powers That Be I didn't have that nonsense to root out of my head.  When I did learn about overt racism, it shocked me.  It shocked me to learn that the KKK still exists.  It shocked me the first time I heard someone say a racial slur in conversation.  I think those things should shock people: we should consider them so atrocious that they stun us to the core.*
      My parents sent me to good schools, that made an effort to teach kids about racism and U.S. history.  The classrooms had posters of famous authors and scientists of many different ethnicities.  During story time, the librarian read us children's tales from China, and India, and Africa.  We diligently revisited the bravery of Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., Rosa Parks, and the other Civil Rights leaders every February.
This is a great example of the kind of equality-promoting propaganda used in my elementary schools.  It took me a long time to realize what was wrong with it.
      What we didn't have - and what I desperately think we were missing - was diversity in the staff and student body.  There were almost no kids of color in my elementary school, and not a single Black kid in any of my classes.  So my understanding of racism was purely academic.  I will give my teachers the benefit of the doubt; they were probably doing what was considered a 'best practice' at the time, and I think they wanted their students to have good values.  I did develop a strong moral value that prejudice based on skin color, language, or culture is wrong.  But I also learned some other lessons, that I've only identified in retrospect:

1) Racism happened long ago/somewhere else
2) Everything was better now
3) Relations between Black & White people were defined by mistrust

      As a psychologist, I now understand the power of learning through observation.  Where our personal experience leaves a void, book learning will fill in--but it will do so imperfectly.  This is what happened to me in early childhood.  Since I didn't know a single Black person, as a little kid I became afraid that Black people would assume I was racist, just because I was White.  I'm not sure I totally got over the misconception until adulthood.  And that anxiety prevented me from taking advantage of a lot of opportunities.
       Moreover, I feel that this mindset unintentionally set me up to be closed-minded about race-relations today.  Since I never SAW any racism growing up, and I had LEARNED about it only from a historical perspective, it was that much harder for me to accept the present day reality.
      I have no idea if anybody else had an experience like mine.  My brain may just work in weird ways.  But through the lens of hindsight, I do have some suggestions for elementary schools:

1) Deliberately integrate schools--there will be another separate post on this
2) Keep teaching about the Black leaders of the past, but also teach about Whites who helped; not to diminish the greatness of the Black participants, but to offer role models for dumb kids like me, who think that the struggle for equality and justice is something other people do
3) Incorporate the history into the present.  Always.  In all topics.  Especially when we have so many present-day challenges to overcome.
This is the kind of poster I wish had been in my schools: seeing and valuing difference, and realizing that helping others means strengthening all.



*Then we need to have the same reaction to systemic racism, like a court system that unevenly punishes African Americans versus Caucasians.  Unfortunately, a lot of privileged White people see those statistics as a glitch.  You can't assume somebody said "wetback" on accident.  You can assume that it's just coincidence Latino drivers get pulled over more often than Whites.

Tuesday, August 16, 2016

Preferential Treatment, Part Two

      This is the second part of a blog post about an experience I had at a restaurant last weekend.  In Part One I outlined the experience as honestly as I could, and the observations I made that led to my thoughts that the staff - almost all ethnic minorities, predominantly Black - were giving preferential service to Black patrons.  I did doubt myself at the time - I still do, as I'm writing this - and I hope that my knee-jerk conclusion is wrong.  I hope that my low blood sugar affected my powers of perception, and made me feel more paranoid and testy than normal.  I really don't like thinking that anybody is exhibiting racial prejudice for any reasons; as I've stated before, I tend to give people the benefit of the doubt.
      That being said, I'm far from ignorant.  I know too well the many different forms that prejudice can take.  And I'm very aware that usually that prejudice benefits me, as a White American woman.  But sometimes it doesn't.  When White people find themselves on the losing side of racial prejudice, they tend to react very negatively.  I'm trying to see this as an opportunity for learning, about myself and the society in which I live.
      So now that I'm thinking back over the events of the morning, my brain goes into Alternate Theory Mode.  (I'm starting to recognize this as my pattern.)  Maybe I missed something, and those tables with Black patrons were seated and ordered earlier than I thought.  Maybe those patrons were owners, or former employees, or family members--if we're being honest, we all give preferential treatment to those individuals.  Or maybe nobody was receiving special attention, and the kitchen just didn't have their act together.  After all, that White family seated to my right got their food more quickly than my husband and I.  It's totally possible that something wonky happened with our order.  There are plenty of perfectly logical reasons for the timing and order of food service that have nothing to do with race.
I realize it sounds entirely silly, but if there was some way to end racism through food, I would drop my career and make that my life's work.
      Then my brain goes into Explore the Meaning Mode.  To lay it out: what if my initial assumption was correct after all?  What does that mean to me?  What does it mean in a larger social context? What can I learn?
      So: if my initial assumption was correct, and my food order was intentionally delayed as the orders of Black patrons (and other minorities, for all I know) were put in the front of the list, what does that mean to me?  My first reaction is indignant anger.  I don't like unfairness in general.  And if I'm being honest, I like it even less when it negatively impacts me--particularly when it comes between me and my breakfast.*  There's a part of my privileged, restaurant experienced brain that says, "That is a piss poor business model, and a great way to alienate customers. Where is your pride in your work?"  I also feel hurt.  I think, "I'm a nice person!  I just wanted to eat breakfast!  Judging me on the color of my skin denies me who I am as an individual!"
      Well, duh.
      Which brings me to the question of a larger social context.  What if the staff there were prioritizing the orders of Black patrons?  What if they were using this restaurant as a space for people who get the short end of the stick in so many ways, so often, and making a small gesture to put them first for a change?
      There area couple problems: I'm pretty sure that giving preferential treatment to customers based on perceived race is illegal.  I say "pretty sure," because if there's one thing I've learned in the last few years, it's that laws vary more from state to state than one might expect.**  But more importantly, it goes against a moral code to which the majority of Americans believe that they adhere.  Given the legacy of the 1960's and the Civil Rights Movement, I think most of us have very strong reactions to blatant exhibitions of racial prejudice, particularly when it comes to service industries.
The Supreme Court abolished segregation in public businesses with the Civil Rights Act of 1964.  The way the law is written, is applies all ways, across all races.
      After segregation became illegal, many business establishments attempted to discourage minorities from coming by treating them badly.  This still happens today, way more often than most people know--or are willing to admit.  And I know exactly how I would react if I thought a restaurant were giving preferential treatment to White customers: I'd call my friends who are lawyers and try to get it shut down.  That being said, I noticed who was receiving food at the restaurant over the weekend because I was the one being kept waiting.  Would I notice if I was the one being moved to the front of the list?
      Historically, how many places gave preferential service to ethnic minorities over White people?  If my order was pushed back in favor of others, still I wasn't refused service, and no real damage was done.  Do I have an ethical leg to stand on in being bent out of shape?
      I don't like unfairness to be encouraged or tolerated in any sense.  It may sound idealistic, but I believe it is detrimental to an individual if they are taught that it's Ok to discriminate for any reason.  I recognize and honor the statistical foundations of Affirmative Action, but I also admit it took me awhile to really believe it was necessary, and to get on board.  I long for the day when the playing field really is level.  Cynically, I doubt that will happen in my lifetime.
      Here's the last thing my brain is processing on this before I get too flooded to continue: what if the restaurant gave preferential service to ethnic minorities, and everybody knew about it?  What if it was something they took pride in, because they wanted to make a political statement?
      Weirdly enough, if that were the case, I think I would make a point of eating there.  There are businesses I boycott because I dislike their politics--this would just be the opposite.  Then I would feel like I was a part of a socio-political statement, instead of a victim of prejudice.  Or even if the employees weren't doing it to make a statement, just to support fellow minorities, if they were honest and open about it, I would patronize their establishment to show my support as well.
      So what does all this say about me?  I guess I don't take kindly to being marginalized.  I don't want ANYBODY being marginalized, especially for utterly stupid reasons like skin color.  But, like most people, I'm more likely to get worked up when I'm the one impacted.



*Remember my three disclaimers from Part One: I am a breakfast-loving foodie who get cantankerous when my blood sugar gets too low.

**Especially in the area of civil rights.  Which is, frankly, downright alarming.

Monday, August 15, 2016

Preferential Service, Part One

      Last weekend, I had an interesting experience at a restaurant.  It was a diner with a cool theme in a city that my husband and I were visiting, and we were excited to check it out.  I did not expect that going out to brunch would bring race-related issues to mind--then again, that's part of being racially privileged, isn't it?  Anyway, I want to be honest about my experience, and objective in my introspection.  To accommodate the length I'm breaking this post into two part.  Part One is a summary of events from my perspective.  Part Two will be my reflections after the fact.  If you're up for it, I would appreciate your willingness to read both, and give me your feedback.
      But before I go any further, here are three things you should know about me, because they probably influenced my experience:

a) I am a foodie.  Not in the snobby way, in the "I really like food - buying it, making it, eating it, learning about it, and experiencing it in a wide variety of places" way.  I am equally happy eating in a hole-in-the-wall Chinese restaurant with peeling wallpaper and mismatched plates as I am stepping into a high-end restaurant with Wagyu beef flown in from Japan on a daily basis.

b) Breakfast is my favorite meal.  Everything from mimosas with eggs Benedict, to black coffee and hashed browns; from asparagus soufflĂ© and brioche, to bacon and oatmeal, I am a breakfast person.


c) Perhaps most importantly, I get "hangry;" when my blood sugar gets too low I turn into a grumpy five year old version of myself.  Experience has taught me to time my meals throughout the day and carry emergency snacks.

      So here's an honest account of my experience at the restaurant. We arrived, and it was crowded, but since the host said the wait was only 15 minutes I wasn't worried.  As we waited for our table, I noted that the restaurant staff - waiters, cooks, host, etc - was made up of predominantly young Black people, a couple Hispanic people, and one individual who appeared White.  My reaction to this, as a professional who tries to work from a social justice perspective, was, "This is awesome!  It would appear that the owners make a point of hiring minorities, who typically experience negative prejudice in seeking jobs.  What a great, practical way to make social impact!"
      We were seated after 14 minutes, so I was a happy camper.  Our server - a young Hispanic woman - was prompt in bringing our water and taking our order.  When I asked for a recommendation on sausage vs. bacon, she answered promptly and with a smile, and I was happy to take her suggestion.**  I sat back, soaked in what the restaurant had done with their theme, and chatted away with my husband.
      At the table to my right was a family of five, all White, who had been seated about 10 minutes before us.  At the table to my left was a Black couple about my age. They were seated right before us, received their water right before us, and put in their order right before we did.  So when I saw the couple's food arrive after about twenty minutes, I expected our food to arrive next.
      Then I noticed the table to my right had not yet received their food.  I was a little surprised, but they did have a couple small kids.  I thought, "Maybe they ordered after we did, or put in a special order for the kids.  That would delay things."  That family got their food about 10 minutes later.  My husband and I were still waiting.
      When the Black couple to my left got their check, and my husband and I had not yet received our food, I started to wonder if our order had gone missing.  Unfortunately, the restaurant was crowded, loud, and busy, so there was no easy way to flag down a server to ask.  Then, before I could exert myself, my husband pointed out that our parking meter was probably about to expire.
      Note: we had paid for 90 minutes on our meter.
This sight does not promote good digestion.
      I was closer to the door, and I wanted to get up and use the washroom anyway, so I volunteered to go check the car.  It was when I got up and started walking that I noticed the effects of my low blood sugar.  My energy was low, my brain felt jammed, and my stomach was growling painfully.  We did, in fact, have only 19 minutes left on the meter, so even if the food had arrived by the time I returned, it was unlikely that we would have made it back to the car in time to avoid a ticket.  So I added another 40 minutes.
      I got back to the restaurant, and our food had not yet arrived.  I went to the restroom to wash my hands, which required squeezing past a table where two Black men were seated, just putting in their order.  I thought, "Good luck, guys, I hope you aren't prone to hunger-crankiness like I am."  When I returned to my table, the food had still not arrived.  At this juncture I began to debate whether or not to eat my protein bar, even though I had ordered a full hot breakfast. I decided to hold out another 5 minutes.  Just as I was about to get my snack, the server brought out our food.
      The food was tasty enough, but nothing fancy, and nothing spectacular.  And home-fried potatoes, three eggs over medium, three strips of bacon, and a muffin do not take an hour to prepare.  I thought, "Well, the place is busy, and maybe the kitchen isn't really big."
      That was when I saw the table with the two Black men receive their food--the ones I'd squeezed past on my way to the restroom.  It had only been15 minutes since they had placed their order.
      So yes, my brain went there.  I thought, "Oh my God, I think the staff is prioritizing the food orders of the Black patrons."
      I didn't say or do anything.  My husband and I were so hungry by that point that we wolfed down our food, paid, and left in under 20 minutes.  And I immediately decided I needed to process the experience in writing--so on to Part Two.



*Yes, I just described two of my favorite places.  No, I cannot afford to eat at the latter more than once every five years, unless someone else is buying.

**She said "bacon," and the bacon was the best part of my meal.